Make your own Cherry Pie Filling from scratch today. Try this filling in your next cherry pie, turnovers, or to top your next cheesecake.
Surprisingly simple to make, this homemade cherry pie filling will be a new staple in your recipe book. This recipe makes a cherry filling that's rich, sweet, and filled with real cherries. No artificial colors or flavors needed!
I love to use this filling for recipes like my Puff Pastry Cherry Turnovers. It also makes the perfect topping for your next cheesecake - or mini cheesecakes.
I also include directions to bake your own cherry pie in the recipe card below.
Benefits of making homemade pie filling
Benefits of making homemade pie fillingWhy make your own cherry pie filling? First of all, you can control everything that's going into your pie, including what's in the filling. Often (but not always), canned pie filling will include artificial colors. If you're not into that, making your own is a great option.
You can also adjust the sweetness of your filling. Add more (or less) sugar to suit your tastes.
I also like to add a dash of cinnamon to my cherry pie filling. It adds an extra layer of warmth and flavor, which is especially nice for Thanksgiving or Christmas.
Pitting cherries
I'm all about quick and easy. I like to buy fresh frozen, pitted cherries most of the time.
It's so easy to pull the bag of cherries out of the freezer about an hour before I plan to start. This way, they're thawed and ready to go.
If you have fresh cherries, no worries. Simply pit your cherries before beginning this recipe. Here is a great article on how to pit cherries without a cherry pitter.
I used the paperclip method today and it was surprisingly easy. Simply insert a paperclip and twist around the pit, then pull the pit out. I'd suggest turning on some music or a tv show while pitting cherries, as it can be tedious.
Or, try a handheld cherry pitter to speed things up. There's also a Cherry Pitter Tool that will pit 6 cherries at once! If you find yourself pitting cherries or olives frequently, this might be for you.
What can I make with cherry pie filling?
- Bake into a pie (directions below)
- Cheesecake topping
- Cherry cheesecake ice cream
- Use as an ice cream topping
- Puff pastry cherry turnovers
- Cherry pie bars
- Use as a pancake topping
Cherry Pie Filling
Ingredients
- 4 cups pitted cherries if frozen, thaw
- 1 cup granulated sugar *
- 2 tablespoons lemon juice
- ¼ cup cornstarch
- ⅛ teaspoon cinnamon optional
To make a cherry pie
- 2 prepared pie crusts top and bottom
- 1 tablespoon granulated sugar optional
Instructions
- In a saucepan over medium heat, add cherries, granulated sugar, lemon juice, cornstarch, and cinnamon. Stir to combine.
- If your cherries are not very juicy, you may want to add water (from a few tablespoons to ½ cup depending on your fruit) to thin your sauce.
- Bring to a boil. Reduce heat to medium-low and cook for 8-10 minutes, or until mixture has thickened (If your mixture is sticking to the pan, turn the heat down to low and add a splash of water). Remove from heat and allow to cool slightly.
Baking into a pie
- Preheat oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Place prepared pie crust into an 8 or 9 inch pie pan. Fill with cherry pie filling, then place top pie crust over filling. Pinch the edges closed, then make a slit in the middle of the pie for steam to escape. Optionally, sprinkle with a tablespoon of granulated sugar before baking.
- Bake for 45-50 minutes, then remove from oven to cool.
Equipment Recommendations
Notes
- *The amount of sugar can be adjusted to suit your tastes - add as little as ½ cup for a less sweet filling. If using sweet cherries, I recommend reducing the amount of sugar to ⅔ cup or less.
- 4 cups of pitted cherries weighs about 21 ounces/616 grams
- Sweet or tart cherries can be used to make pie filling.
- Pie filling can be frozen for up to 3 months in a sealed, freezer safe container. Thaw in the refrigerator overnight before using. Pie filling will thicken when chilled, but will thin out again when heated in the oven.
- Pie filling can be made with fresh or frozen cherries. If frozen, thaw before beginning.
Hi,
I tried your recipe and cake out good. Thank you for good one without preservatives.
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
Delicious! Thank you! Never have made a pie before. Thank you for the easy to follow instructions and pictures!
Hi Heather,
Can your Cherry Pie Filling Recipe be preserved
by the water bath canning method? I used this recipe for
a Cherry -Blueberry pie I made for Memorial Day. I would
love to can it.
Thank-you
Hi Rosaline, I do not have any experience with canning, but I have frozen this cherry pie filling for up to 6 months with success.
Can this recipe be doubled ?
Yes, this recipe can be doubled.
This was amazing! Very easy to make and delicious. Thank you!
Do you use sweet or tart cherries?
Sweet or tart cherries can be used in this recipe! Tart cherries are a popular choice for pies, but I usually use dark sweet cherries (as pictured). If using sweet cherries, I recommend reducing the sugar to 2/3 cup.
This looks lovely, I have a ton of sour cherries to use up. Can I make the filling, then place in a prepared crust and freeze before baking or should it all be baked then frozen? Thank you in advance 🙂
Hi Faith, I'd recommend freezing your pie unbaked. Cover it tightly with foil and it will keep for up to 3 months in the freezer. You can toss it straight in the oven to bake from frozen, but will take at least 20 minutes longer to bake. Hope this helps!
Do I pour off the excess waters after defrosting the cherries?
Hi Ginny, you can add the cherries and their juices to the pan, no need to drain them!
I am currently making the pie filling but I am using fresh canadian bing cherries I never used frozen when the fruit is in season. but the fruit looks dry so I added water since not being formerly frozen there was no moisture. you should add instructions for this if I was a novice baker good fruit would be burnt and ruined! just a suggestion from an old man . I will rate the recipe when the pie is made wish me luck.
Hi Davey, I hope you enjoy your cherry pie! I've made this filling with fresh cherries before with no issue, but you can definitely add a splash of water if they're looking dry. I'd also suggest turning down the heat slightly - if they look like they're going to burn, the heat may be too hot. Please do let us know how your pie turns out!
Great recipe! I used it for small hand pies, and it behaved itself wonderfully, it didn't, seep out and get messy and runny, thank you for sharing the recipe!
Turned out perfectly, tastes so good. Thank you. Will most definitely save this recipe and use again
Loved it!
I used frozen sour cherries from my mom’s tree, added the juice of a lemon and used about 1 1/4 cups of sugar. Turned out so tasty!
This is very similar to the cherry pie recipe I make using Oregon brand canned tart cherries. I got the recipe from my mother-in-law. It uses 2 cans of the tart cherries drained, reserving 1 cup of the juice to mix with the cornstarch and sugar, Cook until thickened and bubbly, then mix in the drained cherries. I actually cook the juice mixture in the microwave stirring frequently. Add 1/8-1/4 tsp of cinnamon and 1/4-1/2 tsp almond flavoring along with cherries. Mix and pour into pie shell then bake. There’s no lemon juice in this recipe. Cinnamon was my MIL’s secret ingredient.
I LOVED the flavor and consistency of this recipe. Sometimes when I’ve used corn starch for cherry pie filling, it has had a kind of “sticky” feel n your mouth. This did not.
But when I put the leftover filling in the fridge to bake with the next day, it was more of a “gel” texture than the smooth filling it was. (Think canned whole cranberry sauce.). I’m still using it for cherry crisp, but I wondered if that was normal and what a pie would be like.
Any ideas?
Thanks!
Hi Candy, I'd guess that your filling thickened up from being refrigerated, and should thin back to normal when baked into your crisp. Let us know how it turns out!
Thanks Heather —
It was better and smoothed out some in the crisp, but still not quite the same as when I first made it. We all gobbled it up and I will definitely keep making this recipe. Thanks again!
I just ruined 4 cups of freshly picked cherries with this recipe. It is way too sweet. A cup of sugar for 4 cups of cherries might work for sour cherries, but if you like the taste of cherries don't use this recipe with sweet cherries. I wish I had checked other recipes before choosing this. Other recipes use half this amount of sugar. My fault for using a random recipe on the internet, but I just wanted to let others know that this is too much sugar.
Hi Starla, I'm sorry to hear that your pie filling didn't turn out! I mention above that the amount of sugar can be adjusted (add more or less) to suit your tastes, but I have also added that note directly to the recipe card for future readers. Thank you for the feedback!
I agree that it’s too sweet (although I figured it would be and used only 1/2 cup of sugar to begin with anyway) but honestly my main complaint is that there is way too much cornstarch and not enough liquid. I put it all in a pan as directed and the cornstarch cooked into little globs of jelly despite stirring and adding extra liquid. I’m surprised there’s no one else having the same problem here. Very disappointed and frankly ruined my fresh cherries.
Hi Ellie, I'm sorry to hear that your pie filling didn't turn out! It's hard to say what went wrong without being in the kitchen with you, but the amount of liquid in the pan can depend on the juiciness of the cherries. More water (up to 1/2 cup) can definitely be added to the pan to thin the sauce. I will make that step more clear in the recipe card for future readers, thank you for the feedback!
I used fresh sweet cherries that I picked from a tree in my back yard. I had a little more that 6 cups of cherries so adjusted the recipe accordingly. As suggested, I decreased the amount sugar since I was using sweet cherries. I also found that I had to add a little water, stir frequently, and lower the heat while cooking so the fruit didn’t stick to the pan. Filling turned out perfectly. Great taste and consistency. Thanks! 🍒